Ethics and Aesthetics: Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs 21:15, August 29, 2016

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail this to someone

Our Resources

Ethics and Aesthetics: Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail this to someone

In our previous post in our Ethics and Aesthetics series we examined affordance theory and the ways that potential actions shape the way we view the world. In 1943 psychologist Abraham Maslow published a paper entitled “A Theory of Human Motivation” containing a now-famous paradigm: the hierarchy of needs. The pyramidal hierarchy outlines basic human needs and desires. It states that human beings must have their basic physiological and safety needs met before they can seek out higher-level needs such as love, self-esteem, and creativity. There is an analogous pyramid relating to design. These five key levels correspond to those of Maslow’s:

   (*)   Functionality – This is the most basic tier of the pyramid. At the very least, a design needs to serve its function. For LawRoom, this means that at the minimum, our courses need to convey information. Each course begins with a series of discussions between instructional writers and subject matter experts on what the course needs to communicate. If our designs stopped here, users would receive a giant block of text to read. Designs at this level are considered low-value.

   (*)   Reliability – The next tier is consistency. Our courses must meet a minimum standard of performance. If a course crashed every time a user tried to do something, it would be frustrating to use, and therefore not particularly useful. Our talented team of programmers ensure that every element in our courses works dependably.

   (*)   Usability – Next, designs need to be easy and forgiving to use. Interface designers ensure that our courses are intuitive and behave the way you would expect them to. For example, the navigation buttons are where you’d expect them to be, and a button with an “X” on it closes a window instead of opening a new one. Designs at this level are considered to be of moderate value. They’ll allow you to do what you need to, but nothing more.

   (*)   Proficiency – At this stage, our courses empower our users to do things better than they did previously. Our robust LMS allows administrators to keep track of vast amounts of data on their users. The LMS stores only the data you allow it to, and has the ability to automatically propagate it throughout our suite of courses to drastically cut down on administrative tasks. Designs at this level are considered to be of high value, and tend to be incorporated into the user’s life in a meaningful way.

   (*)   Creativity – The very top level of the hierarchy allows users to interact with the design in innovative ways. Designs at this level tend to inspire cult-like fandom, and can affect the direction of culture and history. Hartmut Esslinger’s streamlined, elegant designs for Apple changed the way we interact with personal technology, and found homes in the permanent collections of the Whitney Museum and MoMA. Our reports allow university administrators to observe trends over time, and develop programming to address specific needs and issues. Our goal is to effect sustainable social change, and that goal sits at the very top of the design needs pyramid.

As critics of Maslow as well as Maslow himself have pointed out, these levels aren’t always fulfilled in order, nor are they strictly separate. Certain needs in Maslow’s hierarchy, like love, can supersede even physiological needs like food. In a classic study about the power of tenderness and motivation, psychologist Harry Harlow showed how baby monkeys overwhelmingly prefer cuddly terry-cloth surrogate mothers that don’t have food to wire mothers that have milk. Likewise, there may be cases when technical design sacrifices a certain amount of usability in order to induce the user to learn a complicated interface that affords a high degree of control–this is the case for many powerful editing softwares. Or, an innovative design may give up the familiarity implied in usability in order to communicate a new conceptual paradigm. Regardless, Maslow states that if lower-order needs are not met while fulfilling higher-order needs, it introduces instability in the system. People who are starving can still love fiercely, but cannot do so for long. So while our designs aim to affect our users at the highest level, much of our day-to-day efforts go into ensuring that the lower-level needs are being sufficiently met.

LawRoom provides online compliance training on sexual harassment, ethics, FCPA and data security to thousands of companies and universities. To learn more, visit us here:LawRoom.com.

You might also be interested in...

  • Ethics and Aesthetics: Affordance TheoryJuly 12, 2016 Ethics and Aesthetics: Affordance Theory To kick off our Ethics and Aesthetics series we discussed the aesthetic-usability effect, and offered some theories on why beautiful things tend to work better. In our second post, we will examine J. J. Gibson’s theory of affordances, and how the animal propensity for action shapes our […] Posted in online compliance training
  • Course Design Q&A with Jenna StrangeAugust 7, 2016 Course Design Q&A with Jenna Strange A lot of effort goes into LawRoom's online compliance training. Instructional design, thoughtful research, clear writing, practical compliance, and coding are minimum inputs. Course design is another critical input to effective instruction, as shown by research on the aesthetic-usability […] Posted in online compliance training
Jayinee Basu
Jayinee Basu is an instructional writer and part of the creative development team at EverFi. Having earned her BA in Literature/Writing and Political Science at UC San Diego, she is currently finishing a post-bac program at UC Berkeley. She is the author of a book of poems entitled Asuras (Civil Coping Mechanisms 2015).

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

White Paper
Data Security training
for employees

  |   Download White Paper

 

Compliance Course Catalog
  |   Download Catalog